Tuesday, 27 May 2014

Taste Test: Everyday Teas


I realise I am in a fairly small minority in that I always drink premium loose-leaf tea. Despite loving a cup of splosh I only tend to drink one or two cups a day so I figure that it's worth spending a bit extra to ensure they're of a really good quality. But for many people the supermarket is where they do their tea-shopping and I can't deny that for a famously tea-loving country like Britain, teabags are where it's at.




When I have visitors and people doing work on the house they often look with suspicion at my overflowing cupboard of tins of loose-leaf tea so I decided I should buy a box of regular old teabags for just such an occasion. Who knows, maybe a super-speedy cuppa will appeal to me now and then. But if I'm going to drink regular everyday tea I want to know which one is the best. Of course my "best" might not be everyone else's so I should say that this taste test is highly subjective and based on my own personal preferences; but I will try to give a sense of what each tea offered.


I decided to begin with the big four of British teas: PG tips; Tetley; Typhoo and Yorkshire Tea. All are readily available pretty much everywhere; all are cheap - around 3p per cup; and each of them have their champions. I decided to be quite scientific(ish) in my preparation as I didn't want factors such as strength to impact on my tasting. I brewed each cup for 2 mins and added 10ml of milk. These are the results.


PG tips - 2.9p per pyramid bag. I've always thought that I don't really like PG Tips and it turns out I was right. My first thought was "wow, that's bitter". A really malty brew - like an Assam but without any brightness - I just didn't find this cup in any way thirst quenching. There is a rounded quality to the taste that hits the side of the tongue, but it's totally lacking in any refreshing bright notes. I'm sorry to say that this is one cuppa I would never choose.


Typhoo - 2.7p per round bag. This was the brand I had always thought was my everyday favourite. Certainly it's a brighter tea than PG but lacking any strong personality. I found that my whole tongue was more involved when I drank it but I struggled to find anything to write in my notes. An inoffensive cuppa that I'd be happy enough to drink but I wouldn't get too excited about.


Yorkshire Tea - 3.1p per square bag. One of those teas that (in the south anyway) has come to dominate shelf-space in supermarkets in a way that I don't remember from days gone by. This is the most expensive of the teas and unlike the others they suggest you brew for between 3-5 minutes. That is clearly necessary as two minutes definitely wasn't enough and I had to put the bag back in for another couple of minutes. Once brewed I found it not dissimilar to Typhoo: it hit me more on the side of the tongue but I found its flavour quite like Typhoo and for an extra couple of minutes brewing time I'm not sure I would bother to make the effort. I was once told by a master tea-blender that although most teas need to be brewed for between 3-5 minutes, the big bag companies know that very few people will give it longer than 90 seconds and they blend accordingly. Obviously not at Taylor's of Harrogate who make Yorkshire Tea. That's not a bad thing of course but for the extra brew-time I'd go for a good loose-leaf tea.


Tetley - 2.9p per round bag. Wow, what a surprise. I really liked this cuppa. It was bright and refreshing with that Darjeeling quality and hit me right on the back of the tongue. I found it really thirst-quenching and compared to the other three it stood out. In fact I liked it so much I actually finished the cup with a slice of cake. Praise indeed when you consider I have hundreds of others to choose from!


Just for comparison I then did a blind taste test for Coffee Boy and interestingly he ranked them exactly the same as I had with Tetley at the top, PG at the bottom and Yorkshire and Typhoo pretty evenly rated in the middle. Of course this may speak more about our tea-tasting compatibility than anything else but it was interesting nonetheless.

So there we are: for me Tetley was a clear winner. I've read that in recent years Tetley has been the top seller in Britain and on the evidence of this taste test I can see why. If you have a strong preference I'd love to hear about it and if you're thinking of trying something new I'd say, give Tetley a go. I was genuinely surprised by how enjoyable this cup was and if I was in a rush I'd certainly be happy to drink a quick cup. After feeling pretty disappointed by the other three it was quite heartening to find that at least one of the brands that sell by the millions has a really enjoyable taste.


Coming soon: Premium everyday teas compared.

21 comments :

  1. Hi : an interesting post : I find that I cannot drink any of the above in a regular basis hence I do not keep them in my house : my everyday tea of choice is Twinings Everyday which I would guess would be considered premium everyday : sadly I even carry a few around for emergencies : my lovely ma and pa drink PG and I cannot stand it hence the emergency bags come in to play : looking forward to your next review xx

    ReplyDelete
  2. Love this experiment! I'll have to try Tetley teas. I don't usually buy everyday tea bags, but if I had to I probably would have tried Yorkshire, just because ... the box is prettiest. :)

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thanks for the great review. My favourite is Typhoo, but Tetley isn't far behind. I agree about PG Tips though. I'm not much of a coffee drinker but I'd rather have a cup of coffee than PG Tips.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Me too, I drink Typhoo or Yorkshire tea .. PG tips always last on my list

      Delete
  4. Great review - thanks. I've been drinking PG Tips for years but lately have found them to be somewhat insipid. Tetley for me next shop - definitely.

    ReplyDelete
  5. If you want to know real tea, and not these fake brands, go to the source. Assam, Nilgiri, Darjeeling, Keemun, Yunan, Gunpowder. All these marketed fake tea brands, are made from these real teas, but from leftovers mixed with who knows what. They do not dare to call these teas by their real name and ingredients. Because the real teas are soooo much better.

    Yes, I sometimes drink Twinnings, various Earl Grey mixes and stuff, but I am all the time aware that I am not getting the real deal. I also sometimes drink cheap wine, but I know it is not the real deal.

    Do yourself a favor tealovers! Take a trip to a real teashop, selling real tea. Buy a sample of Ching Woo and an Assam tea. Talk to the clerk and let him/her explain how to brew and enjoy your tea properly. (yes! clerks in real shops can actually talk, and happens to be able to really help you as a customer! Mindboggling, right?) Then: Go to your place and have a good time wiht some REAL tea!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anyone who follows this blog knows that I usually only drink loose-leaf teas bought from proper shops. But we all need something speedy sometimes!

      Delete
  6. A Dissenting Vote: I also have an elaborate, perhaps encyclopedic collection of teas from around the world. I find myself regularly reaching for PG Tips. Perhaps I enjoy the bitter taste profile, and find there is a bright note that is hugely refreshing. I had a group of people over to the house, we sampled a range of teas.. You can already guess the favorite. I made a huge batch in a tea urn/samovar with PG Tips.. with a splash of milk - it was hands down the winner - it might be the caffeine talking. Then again, we were secretly using Yak's milk, which is peculiar, and already has lots of high notes to it.. PGT stuff a lot of tea in a bag, and perhaps the huge dose of caffeine is an element... A cuppa PGTips feels a lot more like strong coffee in terms of the buzzz.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think you could be right about the caffeine buzz from PG - it certainly tastes stronger. It's just that lack of brightness that kills it for me. Horses for courses though eh?

      Delete
  7. I’ll take my PG tips or Yorkshire any day.

    ReplyDelete
  8. None of the above. As someone mentioned, get the actual stuff. Keemun, Assam, Estate Ceylon, etc. Not the chopped up pulverized dust rubbish. I'd actually get the genuine Chinese black teas. Yingdehong Black is a personal favorite. You can only get it imported from Canton, China. Tastes rich with sweet nutty notes and a distinct cocoa flavor. With milk, it's like drinking silky smooth milk chocolate without the heavy sugar content

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Really Taste Test: Everyday Teas, smug cnut test to follow maybe

      Delete
  9. Trying Tetley now been on PG for years, if I don't like them I will huff and I will puff and blow your house down, great review

    ReplyDelete
  10. Interesting post. I came across it as after drinking Typhoo and PG Tips for years (it's what my parents always drank) I found some Tetley on offer, and have become a complete convert. It's nice to read this article and understand a bit more about why I like it a lot more (hard to put into words sometimes!). I think it's exactly as you say - 'bright and refreshing'.
    Thanks for the article. Anthony

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for stopping by Anthony. I haven’t had a cup of Tetley for ages but your comment has made me think I need to buy a pack with my next shop.

      Delete
  11. I normally drink Early Grey or Twinnings but noticed my favorite grocery store here in the US also carry PG and Typhoo brands. I finally made the leap and bought a box of each. I will try the Tyhpoo first and then tomorrow or maybe even later the PG.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'll be interested to know your thoughts Luke. Let me know.

      Delete
  12. I have always enjoyed PG and swore it was the best but recently have been drinking Tetley at work so now a little unsure. Both good.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I completely agree about PGTips. Hubby and I have switched from coffee to tea and have tried several brands. Besides the many types of "teas" I already had on hand, we started getting to the nitty gritty with black teas, especially breakfast teas (except for bergamot, of which Bigelow is stronger and wins over Twinings). We have bought the brands above, except for Typhoo, and I will probably get that next based on ratings and description. Of the brands we've had, we keep going back to PGTips - it's satisfyingly strong and I love the packaging with the loose bags and flip top box. I don't rely on caffeine daily with either coffee or tea, but this does kick booty in that department. I'm interested in trying Typhoo as I've seen reviews that say it's consistently strong and flavorful.I loved your review and how you conducted it! I personally steep longer, but I like a really stout cuppa. Thank you for taking the time to review and write your review!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. If you like a really strong cuppa I can see why PG might be for you. Also, I think the lack of brightness is perhaps a better substitution for former coffee drinkers? Have you tried Tetley? How did you find it?

      Delete

nrelate

ShareThis